Why do people think alexander the great was gay

Did alexander the great have children

Director Oliver Stone’s depiction of the Macedonian king as homosexual in the movie “Alexander” was similarly divisive. On one end of the spectrum, various gay rights activists and LGBTQ sites praise Alexander the Great as an iconic “gay hero”. And on the comment section of this video some commenters were saying that the reason why people think Alexander was gay was because how he mourned his friends death in the Achilles story.

In the series, however, which mixes documentary techniques (such as interviews with historians) with dramatizations, Netflix is merely going on the historical evidence that indicates Alexander was. For LGBT history month, guest blogger Prof Lloyd Llewellyn-Jones (Chair of Ancient History, Cardiff University) asks: 'Alexander the Great or Alexander the Gay?' before his talk this week, exploring Alexander's sexuality and popular culture.

The claim that Alexander the Great was homosexual is based on speculation rather than concrete historical evidence. His deep friendship with Hephaestion, while significant, does not equate to a romantic or sexual relationship. It also exists in other species. Also, here is our Argylle review. Look at Pompei, Herculaneum. Page 4 of 6. And just how much "relevance" or empirical fact do you actually believe exists about a man's sex life who lived years ago?!

And then you get all indignant and serious about the silly. Overall, I don't care about the sexuality of Alexander the Great or any other historical figure and I don't know anyone else who does either. Nor is it about the historicity or even the historiography of his sexuality, although these thorny subjects continue to perplex and divide both Alexander-scholars and Alexander-devotees alike.

View detailed profile Advanced or search site with. There was a translation error. Originally Posted by Marc Paolella Such silliness. You have said nothing of ANY relevance. Yes, Virginia ok, homosexuals don't exist, unless they are of course, obscure, negative caricatures in your imagination. Yet, if all necessary modern criteria are applied, this may not be the case; Alexander did not further acceptance of homosexual relations between social classes.

In the animal kingdom, especially amongst our closest "relatives", monkeys, apes, and chimpanzees have been found in the jungles to engage in homosexual activities, as have other species of animals. I have no agenda for or against either of those two classes of people. Originally Posted by MetroWord. My source are books about Greek and Helenistic culture. Skip to content.

It was a very violent era to be a gay era.

Was Alexander the Great Gay or Bisexual?

It is unknown if Alexander the Great was considered gay. Read: homosexuals are the worst thing a man can be and are never positive. He also married three women, Roxana of Bactria, Stateira, and Parysatis, and fathered children with them. Can you solve it faster than others? I agree that I don't find that phrase, alone, to be evidence of him being against homosexuality.

There were no gays, it was cultural and implicit. Originally Posted by NJGOAT No one can prove it or disprove it and Plutarch's musings on the subjects nearly years later are something I would take with a grain of salt, especially because we know that Plutarch wrote his narratives to fit his hypotheses' and mesh well with the story that he wanted to tell.